
In this country we are blessed with some of the most outstanding surgeons in the world. We also have some incompetent surgeons picking up a scalpel. This article is for those of us who want excellence and for those excellent surgeons who deserve our patronage.
One day, maybe in Heaven or Oz, the outcomes of surgeons will be published and easily available for consumers. Until that glorious sunshine day, I believe finding a good used car is easier than finding a good surgeon.
What are outcomes? Examples:
- What is the average hospital stay for a patient having your type of surgery?
- What is the surgeon’s data, gained from patients, on how quickly the pain subsides in one month, in 3 months and in one year?
- What is the frequency of infection rate for this surgeon?
- What is the percentage of complications for this particular surgeon….not for this surgery but for this surgeon?
- How quickly can the patients of this particular surgeon and surgery return to work or to normal activities?
CURRENTLY, HOW DO WE FIND OUT ABOUT SURGEONS?
- Just ask your primary care physician (PCP) you say and trust he/she actually knows of the surgeon’s outcomes.
- Or how about running around and grabbing everyone you see for the name of someone. Of course, you may be labeled as a worrier or even as the “crazy lady”
- How about faith? Just leave it in the hands of God. Well, I think God is calling all of us to demand this public information.
But you, the reader, probably think that information does not exist. Yes, yes it does.
Let me quote from an article I read on the web while I was researching back surgery.
“Results and Outcome Studies”
The results of Minimally Invasive Spinal Fusion (MIS PLF or MIS TLF) surgery in the treatment of symptomatic spondylolisthesis and degenerative disc disease are generally excellent. Numerous research studies in medical journals demonstrate greater than 92-98% good or excellent results from MIS fusion surgery. Most patients are noted to have a significant, rapid improvement of their back pain and return to many, if not all of their normal daily and recreational activities.”
Minimally Invasive Spinal Fusion-USC Center for Spinal Surgery – Los Angeles
http://www.uscspine.com/treatment/min-invasive-spinalfusion.cfm
There are other studies on the web listing outcomes. So, somehow this surgeon did keep data and reported it. We just need access to this data and to the data of all surgeons.
Until then, here are a few tips for those of you not willing to settle on whether a surgeon is “nice”, has “blue or brown or green eyes”, has a “good bedside manner” Yes, you are the rare, the few who want to even odds in your favor as you prepare for this scary journey.
A FEW TIPS UNTIL THERE IS A BETTER WAY:
1. Please do ask your PCP and ask how the PCP knows the surgeon. Is it just a business card with the surgeon’s name? Does your PCP know of other patients who had this surgeon for knee, back, elbow surgery and how are those patients doing?
2. Do ask neighbors, friends, relatives and anyone who might have inside information such as an OR nurse, Physical Therapist, surgical equipment salesmen or even physicians who have integrity to guide you away from shoddiness and into excellence. Be prepared that the professional folks will say things like, “Oh, they’re all good”, “Our hospital just wouldn’t have anyone surgeon with consistent bad outcomes” or worse yet, “We just cannot give out that information”
3. Research the surgeon in all the means possible at the present time.
- Scour the web not just for the surgeon’s web site but for any publications the surgeon may have written. Click on those publications and try to determine if the surgeon has reported outcomes.
- There are some sites available on the web. I am not recommending any of them. This is just for your information:
www.RateMDs.com
www.healthgrades.com
www.vitals.com
DORA (Department of Regulatory Agency) in your state.
http://www.dora.state.co.us (in Colorado)
You may have to search diligently to find any settlements or complaints registered against the surgeon. Also, know that some excellent surgeons have settled lawsuits and this may not be a fair indicator for you. And, conversely, some really ghastly surgeons have no settlements.
4. Interview doctors. I know this is difficult especially if you are in pain or in an emergency. One of the best doctors I found encouraged patients to seek another opinion. I think if this is an excellent surgeon, he/she knows you will compare and return to his/her office.
REASONS WHY SOME FOLKS DO NOT SUE EVEN THOUGH THEY HAVE BEEN TERRIBLY HARMED BY A SURGEON:
Many states have a cap on the amount of money that can be obtained from a law suit. The plaintiff attorney must spend much of the attorney’s time and money in medical records and depositions and see no return on that money or even a monetary loss. This is especially true if the patient is “elderly” or has a disability. The surgeon’s attorneys will argue that these categories of folks, not having much gainful employment, have not lost much. This is sad but true. Sometimes the same offending surgeon is allowed to continue surgery on many others and may never be halted.
So, you might think you can then bypass an attorney and go straight to the surgeon’s insurance company. Not always so. The insurance company also knows the above difficulties with a plaintiff/patient suing and will in effect say, “Go ahead, sue.” The insurance company has tremendous resources to fight the plaintiff/patient and to wear them down.
WHAT ALTERNATIVE DOES SOMEONE HAVE WHEN HARM IS OBVIOUS BUT A LAWSUIT IS NOT AN OPTION:
- You can fill out a complaint with your state’s DORA but this requires filling out a form and you may be asked for medical records that you purchase with your own money.
- Write to the hospital Chief Operating Officer, Chief Medical Officer, Chief Nursing Officer and anyone else in power explaining the sequence of events. Enclose medical records confirming (if they were honestly filled out) the incidences. Send medical records of your follow up care and prognosis.
- If you know of others in your community who have also been victims, ask them to sign with you. This probably will not happen since folks are frightened.
- Tell other folks who are preparing for surgery, not to go to Dr….. However, this again can get you into a legal mess. You can, though, say what your experience was with this surgeon.
YOU HAVE DONE YOUR RESEARCH TO THE BEST OF YOUR ABILITY IN TODAY’S WORLD, NOW WHAT:
- Prior to surgery do a write up a about yourself (see my previous blog, “Spiderman AKA Denver C. Fox.” ) It may endear you to the staff & may mean they will take more precautions with you, “this real person”
http://ramblingalongwithnora.wordpress.com/2010/10/20/spiderman-aka-denver-c-fox/
2. If possible, have an advocate with you the day of surgery. Ministers are great. They represent community authority and quietly tell all that you are a nurtured and nurturing part of their community. They also spread the word about how you were treated. This can be good or bad PR for the surgeon and hospital.
3. Now is not the time to threaten any doctor or hospital personnel.
4. And then, do focus on leaving all of this in the hands of your God. Focus on that and focus on great outcomes. You have done your job.
I truly believe, in the near future, outcomes will be easily accessed.
THAT WILL BE A GREAT SUNSHINE DAY FOR ALL OF US!
